Differences between revisions 72 and 73
Revision 72 as of 2012-02-24 20:48:55
Size: 7565
Editor: WagnerBruna
Comment: fix broken links
Revision 73 as of 2012-02-29 10:13:23
Size: 7783
Editor: proxy01
Comment: Added information about cvs2hg and removed the implied recommendation for it. See http://mercurial.selenic.com/bts/issue2538 for why cvs2hg is broken.
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 3: Line 3:
Line 11: Line 10:
Line 16: Line 14:

* [[ConvertExtension]]
 * ConvertExtension
Line 21: Line 18:
Line 25: Line 21:
Convert to CVS (see [[ConvertExtension#Converting_from_RCS]]) and then use CVS tools. Convert to CVS (see [[ConvertExtension#Converting_from_RCS.29|ConvertExtension#Converting_from_RCS)]] and then use CVS tools.
Line 28: Line 24:
Line 31: Line 26:
 * [[ConvertExtension]] - the convert extension supports simple CVS repositories
 * [[http://hg.gerg.ca/cvs2svn|cvs2hg]] is a branch of cvs2svn with native Mercurial output
 * ConvertExtension - the convert extension supports simple CVS repositories
 * [[http://hg.gerg.ca/cvs2svn|cvs2hg]] is a branch of cvs2svn with native Mercurial output.
Line 37: Line 32:
'''Note''': Mercurial's [[ConvertExtension]] uses a naive algorithm to understand CVS. If your CVS repository contains no tags and no branches, it'll work just fine. If you, and everyone who has ever used your CVS repository, have always tagged/branched the tip of your entire source tree, it should work just fine. But if you have ever played any funny games with tagging or branching, [[ConvertExtension]] will not work. It doesn't even try to handle those cases because it is based on cvs2ps, which doesn't even try to understand the full range of strange things people do with CVS tags/branches. The only tool known to handle all of CVS' weird corner cases is cvs2svn. Luckily, there is now a version of cvs2svn with a native Mercurial backend called cvs2hg. See [[http://hg.gerg.ca/cvs2svn/raw-file/tip/README.cvs2hg|its README.cvs2hg file]] for more information. '''Note''': Mercurial's ConvertExtension uses a naive algorithm to understand CVS. If your CVS repository contains no tags and no branches, it'll work just fine. If you, and everyone who has ever used your CVS repository, have always tagged/branched the tip of your entire source tree, it should work just fine. But if you have ever played any funny games with tagging or branching, ConvertExtension will not work. It doesn't even try to handle those cases because it is based on cvs2ps, which doesn't even try to understand the full range of strange things people do with CVS tags/branches. The only tool known to handle all of CVS' weird corner cases is cvs2svn. Luckily, there is now a version of cvs2svn with a native Mercurial backend called cvs2hg. See [[http://hg.gerg.ca/cvs2svn/raw-file/tip/README.cvs2hg|its README.cvs2hg file]] for more information.  However cvs2hg may generate 'fixup commits' that violate the invariant that [[http://www.selenic.com/hg/rev/1792b8a9422b|parents of a merge changeset shall not be linearly related]]. This means that subsequent operations on the converted repository will [[http://mercurial.selenic.com/bts/issue2538|silently fail]].
Line 40: Line 35:
  * use cvs2svn to convert to Subversion, then ConvertExtension to import the Subversion repository: cvs2hg is faster and more flexible
  * use cvs2git to convert to git fast-import format, then use FastImportExtension to import that: again, cvs2hg is faster and more flexible

* use cvs2svn to convert to Subversion, then ConvertExtension to import the Subversion repository.
 * use cvs2git to convert to git fast-import format, then use FastImportExtension to import that.
Line 48: Line 44:
Line 54: Line 49:
Line 58: Line 52:
Line 68: Line 61:
Line 70: Line 64:
 * [[http://dingoskidneys.com/cgi-bin/hgwebdir.cgi/queue-convert-svn/]] - Patch queue against Mercurial. Patches create a convert-repo hacked to support SVN as a source. Uses the SVN API, not SVN command line + subprocess.  * http://dingoskidneys.com/cgi-bin/hgwebdir.cgi/queue-convert-svn/ - Patch queue against Mercurial. Patches create a convert-repo hacked to support SVN as a source. Uses the SVN API, not SVN command line + subprocess.
Line 73: Line 67:
Line 78: Line 73:
Line 81: Line 75:
The [[PerfarceExtension|Perfarce extension]] allows you to pull changelists from Perforce, and to push Mercurial changesets back to it.  The [[PerfarceExtension|Perfarce extension]] allows you to pull changelists from Perforce, and to push Mercurial changesets back to it.
Line 83: Line 77:
There is also a stand-alone script [[http://hg.omnifarious.org/~hopper/p4_to_hg|p4_to_hg]]
This utility can actually keep two repositories in sync.
There is also a stand-alone script [[http://hg.omnifarious.org/~hopper/p4_to_hg|p4_to_hg]] This utility can actually keep two repositories in sync.
Line 93: Line 86:
Line 97: Line 89:
Line 100: Line 91:
[[http://blogs.sun.com/jglick/entry/teamware_to_mercurial_history_conversions]] http://blogs.sun.com/jglick/entry/teamware_to_mercurial_history_conversions
Line 103: Line 94:

* [[SourceSafeConversion]] - A script to convert a [[WikiPedia:Visual_SourceSafe|Visual SourceSafe]] project to a Mercurial Repository
 * SourceSafeConversion - A script to convert a [[WikiPedia:Visual_SourceSafe|Visual SourceSafe]] project to a Mercurial Repository
Line 107: Line 97:

* [[ConvertExtension]]
 * ConvertExtension
Line 111: Line 100:

* [[http://blog.dabide.no/idabide/2010/10/18/converting-from-tfs-to-mercurial/]]
 * http://blog.dabide.no/idabide/2010/10/18/converting-from-tfs-to-mercurial/
Line 115: Line 103:
[[Tailor]] is a conversion tool that can do simple conversions from a variety of systems. See GenericConversion for details on building your own repository conversion tool.
Line 116: Line 105:
[[Tailor]] is a conversion tool that can do simple conversions from a variety of systems.
See GenericConversion for details on building your own repository conversion tool.

Converting Repositories

Your first option should probably be the ConvertExtension bundled with Mercurial. It supports branches, incremental imports, and a few other nice features, and is maintained by the Mercurial authors. It currently only understands CVS, Subversion, Git, Darcs, Monotone, Bazaar, GNU Arch, Perforce and Mercurial as source formats and Mercurial and Subversion as destination formats.

Otherwise, the following tools may be useful.

1. Arch / TLA / Baz 1.5

2. Bazaar?

3. ClearCase

4. RCS

Convert to CVS (see ConvertExtension#Converting_from_RCS) and then use CVS tools.

5. CVS

Multiple convertors exist for converting from CVS to Mercurial:

Note: Mercurial's ConvertExtension uses a naive algorithm to understand CVS. If your CVS repository contains no tags and no branches, it'll work just fine. If you, and everyone who has ever used your CVS repository, have always tagged/branched the tip of your entire source tree, it should work just fine. But if you have ever played any funny games with tagging or branching, ConvertExtension will not work. It doesn't even try to handle those cases because it is based on cvs2ps, which doesn't even try to understand the full range of strange things people do with CVS tags/branches. The only tool known to handle all of CVS' weird corner cases is cvs2svn. Luckily, there is now a version of cvs2svn with a native Mercurial backend called cvs2hg. See its README.cvs2hg file for more information. However cvs2hg may generate 'fixup commits' that violate the invariant that parents of a merge changeset shall not be linearly related. This means that subsequent operations on the converted repository will silently fail.

In the past, other options have included:

  • use cvs2svn to convert to Subversion, then ConvertExtension to import the Subversion repository.

  • use cvs2git to convert to git fast-import format, then use FastImportExtension to import that.

You can also convert from Mercurial to CVS:

6. Darcs

  • The ConvertExtension supports Darcs.

  • An older sample Darcs conversion script is available in the contrib/ directory of the Mercurial source.
  • Also see Tailor.

7. Git

See GitConversion (incremental).

8. Subversion

The ConvertExtension included in Mercurial 0.9.5 can import Subversion trees. It uses the Subversion API, so it can speak any Subversion repository access protocol. It's a good idea to work against a local copy of the Subversion repository you want to convert. Make a local copy of your svn repo using svnsync.

Examples and details about Subversion interoperability can be found in WorkingWithSubversion.

Converters that work on local repositories or data (faster, if this is an option for you):

Converters that work on remote repositories:

Syncing tools:

  • hgsvn allows you to work on SVN checkouts using Mercurial (mirroring all SVN history in a local Mercurial repository on which you can also do local development). It is useful for managing private branches, submitting patches to project maintainers, have fast local operations instead of slow remote "svn up/log/blame", etc. Also useful as "one-shot" conversion tool if you just remove all the svn directories ("find . -name '.svn' |xargs rm -r") afterwards.

  • SubversionToMercurialSync (like hgsvn, but more primitive)

  • The HgSubversion Mercurial extension. Read about it in its own page on this wiki.

9. Perforce

The ConvertExtension supports conversion from Perforce since version 1.2.

The Perfarce extension allows you to pull changelists from Perforce, and to push Mercurial changesets back to it.

There is also a stand-alone script p4_to_hg This utility can actually keep two repositories in sync.

Currently, it's slapped together and built to serve my particular needs, but it could probably be modified into something more general. It currently makes no attempt to do anything with Perforce's ability to track branches or the movement of changesets from branch to branch. But it hasn't received any love since 2007 or so, and I don't have access to a Perforce repository to use anymore, so I'm not doing any development on it. The other options are probably better. -- EricHopper 2010-10-29 10:29

See also posting http://selenic.com/pipermail/mercurial/2008-July/020241.html: "Start of Mercurial git-fast-import importer (was p4 to hg)" by Paul Crowley

See also posting http://unixsadm.blogspot.com/2010/07/converting-perforce-depots-to-mercurial.html: "Converting Perfoce depots to Mercurial" by Criveti Mihai

10. Bitkeeper

Because of the threatening behavior of Larry McVoldemort of Bitmover, no Bitkeeper conversion tools have been made publicly available. See GenericConversion for details on building your own repository conversion tool.

11. TeamWare

Very experimental conversion script available if you can find nothing better:

http://blogs.sun.com/jglick/entry/teamware_to_mercurial_history_conversions

12. Visual SourceSafe

13. Monotone

14. Team Foundation Server (TFS)

15. Other systems

Tailor is a conversion tool that can do simple conversions from a variety of systems. See GenericConversion for details on building your own repository conversion tool.


CategoryConversion

RepositoryConversion (last edited 2020-07-05 13:34:51 by MarcinKasperski)