Introduction

Mercurial as well as other well-known version control systems cannot version directories. In other words, you cannot add empty directories! A "workaround" for this issue is to use placeholder files which are placed into empty directories. These placeholder files can then be committed into the repository and will make sure that, upon checkout, the directory tree is entirely reconstructed. This solution is also suggested in the Mercurial FAQ. Note however, that using that workaround might not be a good idea. Creating missing directories during a build process should also be considered as an option.

Sometimes a solution where the missing directories are created by some magic is not practicable and people will face the problem of managing such placeholder files. In particular, the problem with using placeholder files is that you need to create them, and delete them, if they are not necessary anymore (because there were added sub-directories or files). With big source trees managing these placeholder files can be cumbersome and error prone.

I have been confronted with such a situation several times now. This is why I decided to write an open source tool which can manage the creation/deletion of such placeholder files automatically. It creates placeholder files in all empty directories. If later on new files or directories are put into such directories, the placeholder files are not necessary anymore and, thus, are removed automatically.

This tool is licensed under the GPLv3 and runs under Mono (Linux) as well as under Microsoft .NET platform (Windows). It can be downloaded here: http://code.google.com/p/markemptydirs/downloads/list

Use Cases

In the following sections some typical use cases are described and it is shown how the tool can help you getting your work easily done. For clarity, I use directory names with upper case letters and file names with lowercase letters in the following examples.

Create placeholder files

Within a directory PROJECT find all "leaf" directories that do not contain any files or sub-directories, and create a placeholder file .emptydir within each such "leaf" directory.

For example, let's assume the following source tree:

[PROJECT]
        |
        *--[DIR1]
        |       |
        |       *--[DIR1-1]
        |
        *--[DIR2]
        |       |
        |       *--file1
        |
        *--[DIR3]

A tree with the corresponding placeholder files will then look like this:

[PROJECT]
        |
        *--[DIR1]
        |       |
        |       *--[DIR1-1]
        |                 |
        |                 *--.emptydir
        |
        *--[DIR2]
        |       |
        |       *--file1
        |
        *--[DIR3]
                |
                *--.emptydir

To create the .emptydir files use the MarkEmptyDirs tool simply like this:

$> MarkEmptyDirs.exe PROJECT

This creates empty .emptydir files. If you want the placeholder files to contain special content there are two ways.

• Provide the content directly on command line:

$> MarkEmptyDirs.exe --text "Do not delete this file." PROJECT

• Provide a template file:

$> MarkEmptyDirs.exe --file template.txt PROJECT

In both cases you can use template variables in your placeholder content which are evaluated everytime a new placeholder file is to be created. The evaluated results then replace the variables. Currently, the following variables are available:

So in order to create template files with a unique id and time information you could do:

$> MarkEmptyDirs.exe --text="CREATOR: §env:USER§§lf§ID: §guid§§lf§TIME: §datetime§§lf:2§Do not delete this file.§lf§" PROJECT

A generated placeholder file might then look like this:

CREATOR: jonnydee
ID: 36358168-b347-4758-adaa-63e198809c32
TIME: 28.07.2009 17:20:30

Do not delete this file.

Using placeholder files with unique content allows to detect renames of directories automatically. Mercurial has such a feature which tries to guess renames by considering file similarities.

Update placeholder files

Let's assume the PROJECT directory has undergone some changes. Directories and/or files have been added and/or deleted. This requires to synchronize the corresponding placeholder files. In particular, some now are not needed anymore and new ones may now be necessary.

For instance, have a look at the following tree:

[PROJECT]
        |
        *--[DIR1]
        |       |
        |       *--[DIR1-1]
        |                 |
        |                 *--.emptydir
        |                 |
        |                 *--newfile.txt
        |
        *--[DIR2]
        |
        *--[DIR3]
                |
                *--.emptydir

DIR1-1 now contains a new file newfile.txt and a previously created .emptydir file. The former now acts as a placholder and, thus, the latter is not needed anymore. DIR2 now is empty and requires a placeholder file.

Consequently, after updating the placeholder files the tree should look like this:

[PROJECT]
        |
        *--[DIR1]
        |       |
        |       *--[DIR1-1]
        |                 |
        |                 *--newfile.txt
        |
        *--[DIR2]
        |       |
        |       *--.emptydir
        |
        *--[DIR3]
                |
                *--.emptydir

Using the MarkEmptyDirs tool for synchronization one would simply do (again):

$> MarkEmptyDirs PROJECT

Delete placeholder files

There are situations where one wants a clean tree which does not contain any placeholder files. So all .emptydir files should be removed.

This can simply be achieved by using the --clean option:

$> MarkEmptyDirs --clean PROJECT

List placeholder files

In order to list all placeholder files just execute:

$> MarkEmptyDirs --list PROJECT

Note that this command is simply a shorthand for:

$> MarkEmptyDirs --short --dry-run --clean PROJECT